Cuyahoga (OH) prosecutor announces 2nd mortgage fraud case
Friday, January 5, 2007 at 12:15PM
On January 4, 2007 Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Bill Mason announced the second, and larger, of two mortgage fraud cases the events behind which took place in 2004 and 2005. A total of 61 defendants were indicted, totaling 269 counts of forgery and theft offenses, telecommunications fraud, and engaging in a pattern corrupt activity, which entailed a fraudulent down-payment scheme and kickbacks to buyers. This case involves 38 properties purchased in Cleveland, East Cleveland, and Garfield Heights with 2.85 million dollars in loans. It comprises 14 key individuals and companies, plus 45 buyers and sellers and other involved parties. In addition, an appraiser falsified two appraisals. Details of the first case can be found in the next article
Prosecutor Bill Mason said, “It’s time to deal with these sham financial and brokerage institutions as they really are – criminals. You predators are now put on notice – those of you who engage in deception in the lending process will face criminal charges in the court room for your duplicity and greed in the board room.”
Click here to view a flow chart, supplied by the Prosecutor, depicting how the scheme worked
Click here for a copy of the indictment
Click here for a Video News report about the case from WKYC TV
The following people are included in the indictment:
Neal Wolf, 30, of East Lake a mortgage broker and owner of Ace Home Loan
Corritha J. Wells, 39, who currently lives in Florida a loan officer for Ace Home Loan [Case dismissed 11/20/2007].
Clarissa Foster, 35 President of Shaker Title Services Corp.
Debora Cofer, 50, of Warrensville Heights owner of third party down-payment providers Diversified Financial
Bettie Simpson, 58, and Willie Simpson, 68, of Macedonia owners of WBS Diversified Management Services, Inc.,
Nayyir Al Mahdi, 36, of Shaker Heights, President of Mary Mae Foundation L.L.C and two other companies, Veil Holdings and Mahdi and Associates
Darnell Tanner, 38, an appraiser of Euclid.
The following 38 properties are mentioned in the indictment
10002 Parkview Garfield Heights, Cleveland, Ohio 44125
1771 Eddy Road East, Cleveland, Ohio 44112
3419 East 75, Cleveland, Ohio 44125
7117 Alice, Cleveland, Ohio
6901 Fullerton, Cleveland, Ohio 44105?
6633 Charter, Cleveland, Ohio
3431 East 75, Cleveland, Ohio
5041 Finn, Cleveland, Ohio 44127
7019 Morgan, Cleveland, Ohio
3439 East 75, Cleveland, Ohio
13505 Gainesboro East, Cleveland, Ohio
1080 East 72, Cleveland, Ohio 44103
2269 East 85, Cleveland, Ohio 44106
296 East 151, Cleveland, Ohio 44110
10306-10 Buckeye Road, Cleveland, Ohio 44104
807 East 95, Cleveland, Ohio 44103
1037 East 78, Cleveland, Ohio 44103
9508 Fuller Cleveland, Ohio 44104
2269 East 100, Cleveland, Ohio
1259 Hayden East, Cleveland, Ohio 44112
12710 Forest, Cleveland, Ohio 44120
1109 East 77, Cleveland, Ohio 44103
10817 Morison, Cleveland, Ohio 44108
1376 East 114, Cleveland, Ohio 44106
13002 Woodside, Cleveland, Ohio 44108
1624 Carlyon East, Cleveland, Ohio 44112
10501 Shale, Cleveland, Ohio 44104
1610 Lakefront East, Cleveland, Ohio 44112
1546-48 Addison, Cleveland, Ohio 44108
7922 Medina, Cleveland, Ohio 44103
4341 West 132, Cleveland, Ohio 44135
12700 Forest Hill, East Cleveland, Ohio 44112
2888 East 111th , Cleveland, Ohio 44104
14613 Strathmore, East Cleveland, Ohio 44112
1310 Lakefront, East Cleveland, Ohio 44112
1257-59 East 146th ,Cleveland, Ohio 44112
2882 East 112th , Cleveland, Ohio 44104
6418 Varian, Cleveland, Ohio 44103
The following people have also been indicted in this case:
TODD WILLIAMS; KATHY J. TAYLOR; BERTHA M. HOUSTON; LORETTA MCDUFFIE; KELLI BLACK; KAMAL ABDULLAH; MAURICE COLLINS; STACEY M. STOUTEMIRE-DOWDY; DOUGLAS THORNTON; CYNTHIA PERSKY; MOHAN R. JAIN; LAKIETA PHILPOT; GEORGE WEHBE; RAJESH K. GUPTA; PATRICK MURPHY; ROBIN DIXON; ERIC CANNADAY; DAVID D. WEISS; MILOW JEVTIC; WILBON ANDERSON III; KENYADA SPATES; ALEX HOLMES, JR; STANLEY WILLIAMS; MARSHELLA KING; JUDITH BRZOSKA [Case dismissed 11/26/2007]; ROBERT HOWARD [Case dismissed on 7/13/2007]; JULIANNE HOWARD [Case dismissed on 7/13/2007]; EDWARD PRATNICKI; ANTONIO COOK; CHARLOTT BROWN; AIDA SCHUMPERT; TUNDA MCFERREN; MICHAEL EWASHINKA; KEVIN WILLIAMS; KORETIA WILLIAMS
The following companies were also mentioned:
REVEST PROPERTIES, LLC; PV COMPANY; SMJ GROWTH CORPORATION; YOUR FIRST CHOICE IN PROPERTY, INC.; AGINCOURT HOLDINGS I, LLC; RKG INVESTMENTS, LLC; OMEGA INVESTSMENTMENT AND CONSULTING COMPANY, LLC; PHASE 4 MANAGEMENT, LLC; GATEWAY HORIZONS
Prosecutor Bill Mason issued a further press release today regarding the arraignments of various defendants, please click here to read it.
Prosecutor Mason said, “These criminals are a scourge on our communities—-leaving them devastated by foreclosure and blight. Their fraud and thievery will not go unpunished.”
In the following press release Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Bill Mason announced that Corritha J. Wells, Clarissa Foster, and Bettie Simpson were collectively found guilty by a jury of 66 mortgage fraud offenses in a seven day trial. This trial involved only 9 of the 38 properties charged in the indictment. Sentencing is set for August 11, 2008 at 10:30 am courtroom 17 B.
Prosecutor Mason said, “Wells and Foster are major players who were
caught conducting their rampant mortgage fraud schemes throughout this
county. Their fate will only get dimmer when we prosecute them for the
remaining houses in this indictment.”
Clarissa Foster, 35, of
Macedonia, was the President of Shaker Title Services Corp, which is
now out of business. Foster’s mother and employee, Bettie Simpson, 60,
of Macedonia, was the Operations Manager for Shaker Title. Corritha J.
Wells, 41, of Cleveland, was a former licensed mortgage loan officer
with the now defunct Ace Home Loan, Inc.
All three participated in a mortgage fraud scam that enabled five buyers, including Wells, to purchase 9 houses for a total of $846,000 using loans totaling $746,450. One house was located in Garfield Heights, one in East Cleveland, and seven in Cleveland. Five of these houses fell into foreclosure. Property information is listed below.
Wells submitted fraudulent loan applications and participated in using third party down payment providers unbeknownst to the lender, Argent Mortgage Company of California. The documents submitted to Argent stated the buyers had bank accounts with certain amounts and that Foster and Simpson were providing the down payment money. But the accounts were bogus. Further, Foster and Simpson provided the third down payment money, and withheld that information from the lender when Shaker Title closed the loan.
These three defendants were indicted in a large mortgage fraud case totaling over $3,000,000 in fraudulent loans in January 2007 that involved 38 properties and 62 defendants. For these 9 properties, Wells was charged with 44 counts and was convicted on all counts; Foster was charged with 27 counts and convicted of 20 counts; and Simpson was charged with 12 counts and convicted of 2 counts. They are the last defendants in this case; all of the charges against the other defendants have been resolved. Due to the large number of properties involved with Foster, Wells and Simpson, the court limited the number of properties presented to the jury at one time. The remaining houses and charges against these defendants will be tried at a later date.
Clarissa Foster, 35, of Macedonia, was the President of Shaker Title Services Corp, which is now out of business. Foster’s mother and employee, Bettie Simpson, 60, of Macedonia, was the Operations Manager for Shaker Title. Corritha J. Wells, 41, of Cleveland, is set for sentencing on August 21, 2008 in courtroom 17 B for her criminal conduct as a former licensed mortgage loan officer with the now defunct Ace Home Loan, Inc. involving the same and additional properties. All three participated in a mortgage fraud scam that enabled five buyers, including Wells, to purchase 9 houses for a total of $846,000 using loans totaling $746,450. One house was located in Garfield Heights, one in East Cleveland, and seven in Cleveland. Six of these houses fell into mortgage or tax foreclosure. Property information is listed below.
On June 11, 2008, Foster was convicted by a jury on a total of 20 counts, comprised of eight (8) counts of Securing Records by Deception, fourth degree felonies; nine (9) counts of Receiving Stolen Property, fifth degree felonies; one (1) count of Securing Records by Deception, a third degree felony; two (2) counts of Theft, fifth degree felonies. Simpson was convicted by a jury on two (2) counts of Receiving Stolen Property, fifth degree felonies.
DA’s Press Release
Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Bill Mason announced that Shaker Title President Clarissa Foster was sentenced to a total of 7 years in prison for mortgage fraud activity after two trials involving 31 houses. Corritha Wells, the mortgage broker for these houses, was also sentenced to 7 years in prison on August 21, 2008. Twenty-six (26) or 84% of the 31 houses fell into foreclosure. See below for information on the properties.
Clarissa Foster, 35, of Macedonia, was the president of Shaker Title Services, which is now defunct. Her mother, Betty Simpson, 60, of Macedonia, was the Operations Manager for Shaker Title. Corritha J. (C.J.) Wells, 42 of Cleveland, was a mortgage broker for Ace Home Loan, Inc., now defunct.
After a six day trial starting on August 25, 2008, the jury found Clarissa Foster guilty on all 44 mortgage fraud counts concerning 22 houses; the jury found her mother, Bettie Simpson, not guilty. Foster and Simpson participated in a mortgage fraud scam that enabled 13 buyers to purchase 22 houses for a total of $1,214,000 using fraudulent loans totaling $956,800. Seventeen houses were located in Cleveland and five in East Cleveland. Eighteen or 82% of these houses fell into mortgage or tax foreclosure.
Foster submitted fraudulent third party down payments unbeknownst to the lender, Argent Mortgage Company of California. The documents – copies of official bank checks - submitted to Argent stated the buyers made the down payments when, in fact, other parties, one of whom pled guilty and testified against Foster, actually provided the down payment money. When the deal closed, this money, plus a fee, was paid back to these providers by the sellers, who were also indicted and who pled guilty. The lender was also not aware that the down payment money went back to these providers. The jury found that Foster, but not Simpson, deceived the lender by informing the lender that the buyer paid the money and by withholding the what actually occurred from the lender when Shaker Title closed the loan.
In June 2008, Foster and Simpson went to trial with mortgage broker Corritha Wells. On June 11, 2008, all three were each found guilty of mortgage fraud related charges concerning the purchase of 9 houses for a total of $846,000 using loans totaling $746,450. One house was located in Garfield Heights, one in East Cleveland, and seven in Cleveland. Six of these houses fell into mortgage or tax foreclosure. On August 11, 2008, Foster was sentenced to five years in prison and ordered to pay $100,000 as restitution to the lender. Simpson was sentenced to three years community control sanctions and ordered to pay $1,000 as restitution to the lender.
On August 21, 2008, Wells was sentenced to 7 years in prison and ordered to pay $100,000 as restitution to the lender. Wells, who was found guilty by a jury on 44 counts of mortgage fraud related offenses involving 9 houses, decided to not to go trial on the remaining 22 houses. She pled guilty to 22 counts of mortgage fraud offenses.
Wells, Foster and Simpson were indicted in a large mortgage fraud case totaling over $3,000,000 in fraudulent loans in January 2007 that involved 38 properties and 62 defendants. They are the last defendants in this case to be tried; all of the charges against the other defendants have been resolved.
| STREET | ADDRESS | CITY | WARD | SALE PRICE | ARGENT LOAN AMOUNT | FORECLOSURE: MORTGAGE OR TAX | |
| 1 | BUCKEYE Road | 10306-10 | Cleveland | 4 | $98,000 | $88,200 | Mortgage |
| 2 | EAST 112th Street | 2882 | Cleveland | 4 | $85,000 | $58,500 | n/a |
| 3 | FINN Avenue | 5041 | Cleveland | 5 | $75,000 | $67,500 | Mortgage |
| 4 | SHALE Avenue | 10501 | Cleveland | 6 | $85,000 | $76,500 | Tax |
| 5 | EAST 85th Street | 2269 | Cleveland | 6 | $90,000 | $76,600 | n/a |
| 6 | EAST 95th Street | 807 | Cleveland | 8 | $95,000 | $82,800 | Tax |
| 7 | EAST 77th Street | 1109 | Cleveland | 8 | $80,000 | $68,000 | Mortgage |
| 8 | WOODSIDE Avenue | 13002 | Cleveland | 9 | $92,000 | $82,800 | Mortgage |
| 9 | EAST 151st Street | 296 | Cleveland | 11 | $105,000 | $94,500 | Mortgage |
| 10 | MORGAN Avenue | 7019 | Cleveland | 12 | $76,000 | $68,400 | Mortgage |
| STREET | ADDRESS | CITY | WARD | SALE PRICE | ARGENT LOAN AMOUNT | FORECLOSURE: MORTGAGE OR TAX | |
| 11 | EAST 75th Street | 3439 | Cleveland | 12 | $78,000 | $70,200 | Tax |
| 12 | CHARTER Avenue | 6633 | Cleveland | 12 | $80,000 | $70,200 | Mortgage |
| 13 | EAST 75th Street | 3431 | Cleveland | 12 | $70,000 | $59,500 | n/a |
| 14 | WEST 132nd Street | 4341 | Cleveland | 20 | $100,000 | $85,000 | Mortgage |
| 15 | LAKEFRONT Avenue | 1610 | East Cleveland | n/a | $81,000 | $72,900 | Tax |
| 16 | EAST 72nd Street | 1080 | Cleveland | 7 | $77,000 | $69,300 | Mortgage |
| 17 | EAST 111th Street | 2888 | Cleveland | 4 | $89,000 | $75,650 | Mortgage |
| 18 | STRATHMORE Avenue | 14613 | East Cleveland | n/a | $88,000 | $79,200 | Mortgage |
| 19 | LAKEFRONT Avenue | 1310 | East Cleveland | n/a | $82,000 | $69,700 | Tax |
| STREET | ADDRESS | CITY | WARD | SALE PRICE | ARGENT LOAN AMOUNT | FORECLOSURE: MORTGAGE OR TAX | |
| 20 | GAINESBORO | 13505 | East Cleveland | n/a | $89,000 | $80,100 | Mortgage |
| 21 | FOREST HILL EAST | 12700 | East Cleveland | n/a | $85,000 | $72,250 | Mortgage |
| 22 | VARIAN Avenue | 6418 | Cleveland | 13 | $85,000 | $76,500 | n/a |
| 23 | ADDISON Road | 1546-48 | Cleveland | 7 | $92,000 | $82,800 | Tax |
| 24 | MEDINA Avenue | 7922 | Cleveland | 7 | $85,000 | $72,250 | Mortgage |
| 25 | FULLERTON Avenue | 6901 | Cleveland | 12 | $85,000 | $76,500 | Mortgage |
| 26 | ALICE Avenue | 7117 | Cleveland | 12 | $74,000 | $62,900 | Mortgage |
| 27 | PARKVIEW Avenue | 10002 | Garfield Heights | n/a | $136,000 | $117,000 | Mortgage |
| 28 | MORISON Avenue | 10817 | Cleveland | 8 | $92,000 | $81,000 | Mortgage |
| STREET | ADDRESS | CITY | WARD | SALE PRICE | ARGENT LOAN AMOUNT | FORECLOSURE: MORTGAGE OR TAX | |
| 29 | EAST 114th Street | 1376 | Cleveland | 9 | $90,000 | $85,500 | Mortgage |
| 30 | EAST 146th Street | 1257-59 | Cleveland | 9 | $86,000 | $77,400 | n/a |
| 31 | EDDY Road | 1771 | East Cleveland | n/a | $106,000 | $90,100 | Mortgage |
The cases against the following people were dismissed:
JUDITH BRZOSKA [Case dismissed 11/26/2007];
ROBERT HOWARD [Case dismissed on 7/13/2007];
JULIANNE HOWARD [Case dismissed on 7/13/2007]
CORRITHA J WELLS [Case dismissed 11/20/2007]



Reader Comments